Court rulingPa. Superior Court
Tap-to-agree arbitration terms: what they mean for people hurt in PA
A published Pennsylvania Superior Court opinion requires strict proof that an app or website user agreed to arbitration, including screens that explicitly tell the user they are waiving a jury trial.
Narration voice and music are AI-generated.
You tick a box to book movers or buy a product online, and the terms behind it send disputes to arbitration instead of court. If you are later hurt, does that tick cost you a jury? In 2026, Pennsylvania's Superior Court and a federal court in eastern Pennsylvania applied different tests.12
Three rulings from courts in Pennsylvania
January 21, 2026
In the Uber case, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania held that the order sending the case to arbitration could not be appealed right away, and vacated the Superior Court's 2023 ruling that there was no valid arbitration agreement.34
March 3, 2026
In the Dolly case, the Superior Court held in a published opinion that a moving-services website gave no reasonably obvious notice of its terms, so there was no real agreement.1
June 24, 2026
A federal court in eastern Pennsylvania compelled arbitration of a personal-injury suit over dental aligners bought online.2
The Uber case was a negligence suit filed after a passenger used the Uber app to get a ride.34 To sign up with Dolly, the customer had to click a box that said "By checking this box I accept the Dolly Terms of Service".1
IllustrationWhat the law says in Pennsylvania's state courts
The Pennsylvania Constitution, article I, section 6, says "Trial by jury shall be as heretofore, and the right thereof remain inviolate".1 Reading that provision to give greater protection to the jury right, the Superior Court held in the Dolly case that "a strict burden of proof is necessary to demonstrate a person's unambiguous manifestation of assent to arbitration".1 It set two requirements:1
- The registration website and app screens must explicitly state that the consumer is waiving a jury trial, and registration cannot be completed until the person is fully informed of that waiver.1
- When the terms sit behind a hyperlink, the waiver should not be hidden in the middle of the document and should appear prominently in bold, capitalized text.1
the registration cannot be completed until the person is fully informed of that waiver”1
The court added that arbitration must be defined within the agreement.1 Dolly's screens did not explicitly state that the consumer was waiving a jury trial.1
Mock screen written for this explainer. Not a real app, company or agreement.
Check a sign-up screen against the Superior Court's requirements
Switch on the screen features the Superior Court's opinion names. The readout says which of its two requirements the mock screen meets, whether the terms define arbitration (which the court also said is needed) and, beside it, what a federal court said on June 24, 2026.
“Trial by jury shall be as heretofore, and the right thereof remain inviolate.” Pennsylvania Constitution, article I, section 6, as quoted in the opinion1
“Clickwrap” refers to the assent process by which a user must click “I agree,” but not necessarily view the contract to which [he or] she is assenting.The definition the opinion quotes1
This mock screen meets 0 of 3 items: the Superior Court's two requirements, plus its statement that arbitration must be defined. First requirement: does not meet. Second requirement: does not meet. Also stated: arbitration defined: does not meet.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, precedential opinion, March 3, 2026 (2026 PA Super 41)1
The court held that “a strict burden of proof is necessary to demonstrate a person’s unambiguous manifestation of assent to arbitration.”1
Does not meet the listed requirement
First requirement
The first requirement is that the registration website and app screens explicitly state that the consumer is waiving the right to a jury trial, and that registration cannot be completed until the person is fully informed of that waiver.1
Missing: the screen does not state the waiver; sign-up is not locked until the box is checked.
The opinion's words
“explicitly stating on the registration website and application screens that a consumer is waiving their right to a jury trial when the person agrees to the seller’s terms of service and the registration cannot be completed until the person is fully informed of that waiver”1
Does not meet the listed requirement
Second requirement
When the terms open from a link, the waiver should not be hidden in the middle of the document but should appear prominently in bold, capitalized text.1
Missing: the waiver does not appear prominently in bold capitals.
The opinion's words
“the waiver should not be hidden in the middle of the document but should appear prominently in bold, capitalized text.”1
Does not meet the listed requirement
Also stated: arbitration defined
The Superior Court said arbitration must be defined within the arbitration agreement and the jury-trial waiver must be prominently displayed.1
Missing: arbitration is not defined in the agreement.
The opinion's words
“arbitration must be defined within the arbitration agreement”1
U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, memorandum, June 24, 20262
This column does not change with the switches.
The en banc Uber decision is the Superior Court's 2023 ruling in the Uber case, made by an expanded panel of its judges and later vacated.src
- The federal court declined to apply the strict standards of the en banc Uber decision.2
- The federal court said that because it was vacated, the en banc Uber decision has no precedential value, despite the Superior Court opinions that have applied it this year.2
- The federal court said federal district courts are not bound by Pennsylvania Superior Court decisions.2
- In an online consumer purchase, the federal court said, intent to be bound turns on whether the buyer received reasonable notice of the arbitration agreement.2
On the agreement in front of it: The federal court found that the aligner agreement defined arbitration and explicitly told users they were giving up their right to a jury trial.2
Not a prediction of how any court will rule. This compares a mock screen with what one opinion required. It says nothing about whether any agreement binds anyone.
- What this shows
- The two requirements one precedential Superior Court opinion set for an online sign-up, plus its point that arbitration must be defined, checked against a mock screen, next to what one federal memorandum said about those standards.
- What it does not show
- Whether any real agreement binds anyone, or how any court will rule. The federal column does not move with the switches, because the memorandum declined to apply these standards.
Uber had asked the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania whether the Superior Court's "special-notice rule for enforcing online arbitration agreements" violates the Federal Arbitration Act, which generally makes written arbitration provisions enforceable.56 Its January 21, 2026 decision did not address that question.34
On May 1, 2026, in a published opinion in a later case against Empower Finance, a company that offers cash advances through a smartphone app, the Superior Court called the Dolly decision "not just instructive, but also controlling" and applied its test.7 That opinion explained that the Supreme Court's Uber decision rested on procedural grounds, which kept the Supreme Court from either approving or disapproving the strict test.7 The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania has not decided whether the strict test is correct.7
Why a federal court went the other way
The aligner suit began in the Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas, and on April 1, 2026, the defendants moved it to federal court.2 Applying Pennsylvania law, that court said intent to be bound in an online purchase turns on whether the buyer received reasonable notice of the arbitration agreement.2
The 2023 Uber decision had come from an expanded nine-judge panel of the Superior Court.4 The federal court said that decision, once vacated, "has no precedential value" (it binds no court), and that federal district courts are not bound by Superior Court decisions.2 It declined to apply the 2023 decision's strict standards, as it said other district courts in the Third Circuit have.2 It treated the Superior Court's 2026 decisions applying those standards, the Dolly case among them, as persuasive authority on Pennsylvania law, meaning worth weighing though not binding, and found the facts of those cases different from the aligner case.2
The buyer had checked a box agreeing to a document containing the arbitration agreement, linked in blue, underlined font.2 The court found those terms "reasonably conspicuous to a reasonably prudent internet user" even though she could finish her purchases without reading the jury waiver: she had inquiry notice, in plain terms enough of a signal to look further.2 Unlike Dolly's terms, the court said, these defined arbitration and explicitly told users they were giving up a jury trial.2
IllustrationIn plain terms, the same sign-up screen can face different tests in state and federal court.
If a company says you agreed to arbitrate
Two years
is generally Pennsylvania's deadline to sue for an injury or death caused by another's negligence (42 Pa.C.S. § 5524).8 Some claims have shorter deadlines.
Questions about how this affects you?
If you or someone in your family was hurt and you want to understand your options, you can talk with a lawyer at CM Injury at (267) 936-2233. The conversation is free and confidential.
Sources
- Duffy v. Tatum, No. 483 EDA 2025, 2026 PA Super 41 (Pa. Super. Mar. 3, 2026), opinion (J-A30025-25)Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania (pacourts.us)
- McCormack v. Dentsply Sirona, Inc., No. 26-cv-2154 (E.D. Pa. June 24, 2026), memorandum (govinfo, USCOURTS-paed-2_26-cv-02154-0)U.S. Government Publishing Office (govinfo.gov)
- Chilutti v. Uber Technologies, Inc., No. 58 EAP 2024 (Pa. Jan. 21, 2026), majority opinion (J-59-2025)Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania (pacourts.us)
- Chilutti v. Uber Technologies, Inc., No. 1023 EDA 2021, Pa. Super. memorandum on remand (J-E01003-23), filed April 10, 2026Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania (pacourts.us)
- Chilutti v. Uber Technologies, Inc., No. 257 EAL 2023 (Pa. Aug. 27, 2024), per curiam order granting allowance of appealUnified Judicial System of Pennsylvania (pacourts.us)
- 9 U.S.C. § 2, Validity, irrevocability, and enforcement of agreements to arbitrate (Cornell LII)Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- Pierce v. Empower Finance Inc., No. 609 WDA 2025, 2026 PA Super 91 (Pa. Super. May 1, 2026), opinion (J-A02006-26)Superior Court of Pennsylvania slip opinion, as archived by CourtListener (Free Law Project)
- 42 Pa.C.S. § 5524, Two year limitation (palegis.us)Pennsylvania General Assembly (palegis.us)
Attorney Advertising. CM Injury (Cavaliere & Mangiaracina, PLLC), 161 Washington Street, Suite 1010, Conshohocken, PA 19428. Reviewed by Michael Cavaliere. (267) 936-2233.
This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts.
Images: Illustration.
How we report: our sources, fact-checking and corrections.



