Skip to main content

Court rulingPa. Supreme Court

Delayed cancer diagnosis case belongs with a jury, Pa. high court says

If a doctor's delay or mistake raised your risk of harm and you were harmed, the chance it would have happened anyway does not by itself end your case.

On October 29, 2026, in Smith v. Kannarkatt, No. 17 MAP 2025, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania issued a ruling addressing the "increased risk of harm" standard for proving that an alleged delay in correctly diagnosing a patient's cancer caused her harm.1 In a unanimous opinion, the court held that the Superior Court applied that standard correctly and that the evidence was enough to send the case to a jury, and it affirmed, or upheld, the order for a new trial.1

What it means for you: In Pennsylvania, if a doctor's delay or mistake raised your risk of harm and you were harmed, the chance it would have happened anyway does not by itself end your case.1 An expert usually must still say the care fell short.1 If the expert is reasonably medically certain the failure raised the risk, that can be enough for a jury to decide whether it played a real part in the harm.1 Ask for your full records.

“…[the] defendant failed to exercise reasonable care in performing an undertaking to render services to a patient which the defendant should recognize as necessary for the other's protection, that this failure increased the risk of physical harm to the patient, and that such harm did in fact result.”1

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, majority opinion, quoting Hamil v. Bashline (1978)Highlight addedRead the opinion, page 2

The question the court took

The trial judge ended this case before a jury could decide it; the two higher courts said a jury should decide it.1 In York County, the plaintiffs, meaning the people bringing the case, alleged that a treating oncologist was negligent, meaning the care fell short, in, among other things, failing to consult with pathology to rule out other cancers.1 At a second trial, the judge ended it with a compulsory nonsuit, concluding there was not sufficient evidence to prove causation, meaning the care caused the harm.1 The Superior Court vacated, or set aside, that judgment and ordered a new trial.1

The rule, step by step

Usually, the plaintiff must present an expert who testifies, to a reasonable degree of medical certainty, that the doctor departed from accepted standards and that this caused the harm.1 When the harm might have happened regardless of the quality of the treatment, Hamil v. Bashline, 392 A.2d 1280 (Pa. 1978), relaxed that burden: expert testimony that the failure raised the risk can send the case to a jury, which still decides whether the failure was a substantial factor in the harm.1

How a delayed-diagnosis case reaches a jury under Hamil

  1. 1

    Care fell short. An expert testifies that the doctor failed to use reasonable care in services the doctor should have recognized the patient needed for protection.1

  2. 2

    The risk went up. The expert testifies, with a reasonable degree of medical certainty, that this failure increased the risk of physical harm, and that the harm did result.1

  3. 3

    The judge's limit. A nonsuit is proper only if a jury, viewing the evidence in the plaintiff's favor, could not reasonably find the elements of the claim.1

Then: Once there is testimony that a failure to detect cancer in time increased the risk of harm, the jury, not the expert, balances the probabilities and decides whether the negligence was a substantial factor.1

What has not changed. The plaintiff still has to prove causation by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning more likely than not.1 The court added that the jury is under no obligation to find the plaintiffs' evidence credible or give it any weight.1 The defense can still call its own experts to say survival was unlikely even with proper care, and conflicting testimony is for the jury.1

How the court applied it

The court found the trial testimony was enough to send the case to a jury, reading it in the light most favorable to the plaintiffs.1 On that view, a pathologist reviewed a biopsy and diagnosed metastatic (spreading) breast cancer.1 Follow-up testing found no sign of a primary tumor and did not suggest the cancer began in the breast.1 The computed tomography (CT) and positron emission tomography (PET) scan results listed lymphoma as a possible alternative diagnosis.1 The treating oncologist had access to the records and their competing impressions.1 The patient received inappropriate chemotherapy for about thirteen months before she was found to have had a rare and aggressive lymphoma all along.1 She died in January 2019.1

In the court's summary, the plaintiffs' standard-of-care expert said the pathology diagnosis was compatible, not diagnostic, meaning pathology was not certain.1 That expert said the oncologist had an obligation to raise the inconsistencies with the pathology team.1 Another expert testified, to a reasonable degree of medical certainty, that the delay deprived the patient of "a substantially better opportunity for a longer life".1

The court said the defense's arguments were largely based on a selective review of the record or otherwise went to how much weight and belief the testimony deserved, not whether there was enough of it.1 It rejected the argument that the plaintiffs had to show a call to the pathologist would have changed the diagnosis, treatment and overall outcome.1

What is still open

No one has yet decided whether the oncologist's conduct was a substantial factor in the harm; that is for a jury to decide at the new trial.1 Whether to abolish or change the Hamil standard was outside the question the court agreed to decide.1

If this happened to you

Pennsylvania requires an action for injury, or for a death caused by negligence, to be started within two years.2 A malpractice case also needs a certificate of merit, a filing that can rest on an appropriate licensed professional's written statement that there is a reasonable probability the care fell outside acceptable standards and was a cause of the harm; it is due with the complaint or within sixty days after it.3 A Pennsylvania wrongful death action exists for the benefit of the spouse, children or parents.4 A lawyer can tell you when the two-year period starts in your case.

Questions about how this affects you?

If you or someone in your family was hurt by a delayed or missed diagnosis and you want to understand your options, you can talk with a lawyer at CM Injury at (267) 936-2233. The conversation is free and confidential.

Sources

  1. Estate of Smith v. Kannarkatt, No. 17 MAP 2025 (Pa. Oct. 29, 2026), majority opinionUnified Judicial System of Pennsylvania (pacourts.us)Retrieved November 18, 2026
  2. 42 Pa.C.S. § 5524 (palegis.us)Pennsylvania General Assembly (palegis.us)Retrieved November 18, 2026
  3. Pa.R.C.P. 1042.3 (Pa. Code)pacodeandbulletin.govRetrieved November 18, 2026
  4. 42 Pa.C.S. § 8301 (palegis.us)Pennsylvania General Assembly (palegis.us)Retrieved November 18, 2026

Attorney Advertising. CM Injury (Cavaliere & Mangiaracina, PLLC), 161 Washington Street, Suite 1010, Conshohocken, PA 19428. Reviewed by Michael Cavaliere. (267) 936-2233.

This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts.

Images: Illustration.

How we report: our sources, fact-checking and corrections.

We Win Big
Tell Us What Happened

Free, no obligation.