Court rulingPa. Supreme Court
Late wages and interest paid in full before suit leave no add-on claim
Pennsylvania law can add 25% of the wages due when pay stays unpaid, but not if your employer pays it all, with interest, before you start a claim.

On October 29, 2026, in Aita v. NCB Management Services, Inc., No. 25 MAP 2025, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania issued a ruling addressing liquidated damages under the Wage Payment and Collection Law (WPCL).1 The Court held that the law does not let an employee start a case for liquidated damages after the employer fully pays all owed wages and statutory interest.1
Pennsylvania law can add 25% of the wages due, or $500 if that is more, when pay stays unpaid past set deadlines and there is no honest dispute over it.1 If your employer pays it all, with interest, before you start a claim, you can no longer claim that add-on.1 It can still apply to wages unpaid when you start, within the law's limits.1 Keep dated records, and start any claim within three years of the due date.1
For example, say a worker's paycheck is still unpaid thirty days after her regular payday, and her employer has no good faith dispute over it.1 If the employer then pays it in full, with interest, before she starts a claim, she cannot claim the add-on.1 If the pay is still owed when she starts her claim, within three years of the payday, she may also claim the add-on.1
In this case, twelve of the chief executive's earned monthly retention bonuses were not paid on time.1 His employer, NCB, later paid them, plus 6% interest, in July and October 2017.1 In February 2019 he filed a WPCL claim seeking only liquidated damages (in plain terms, the add-on) and attorneys' fees.1
Can a worker still claim the add-on?
- 1
Wages unpaid past the law's deadline. The add-on applies when wages remain unpaid beyond set time periods.1 With a regular payday, that is thirty days past it;1 with none, it is sixty days after a proper claim or after the agreement, award or other act making the wages payable.1 Shortfalls over 5% of gross wages on two paydays in the same calendar quarter also count.1
- 2
No good faith dispute. It is not available where a good faith (honest) dispute over the wage claim accounts for the non-payment.1
- 3
Wages still owed when the case starts. The claim must be for wages the employer has not yet paid when the case starts.1
- 4
Filed within three years. No WPCL case for unpaid wages or liquidated damages can be started more than three years after the day the wages were due and payable.1
Then: The worker may claim, in addition, 25% of the total wages due or $500, whichever is greater.1
The case and how it reached the Supreme Court
The executive won in the first two courts and lost in the third.1
February 2019
The executive filed his WPCL claim.1
January 21, 2022
The trial court ruled for the executive without a trial.1
2024
In a 5-4 published opinion, an en banc (larger panel) majority of the Superior Court upheld that ruling.1
October 29, 2026
The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania reversed.1
The Superior Court had said a worker can sue for the add-on whether or not the employer paid all wages owed before the case started.1 Otherwise, it reasoned, an employer could drag its feet for months and escape the add-on by paying just before the employee files suit.1 The Pennsylvania Department of Labor and Industry (L&I) filed a friend-of-the-court brief agreeing with the Superior Court and the executive.1
What the Supreme Court decided
The Court sided with the employer.1 Justice Mundy wrote the majority opinion,1 and five other justices joined it.1
The Court said 43 P.S. § 260.10, the add-on section, "does not authorize a standalone claim for liquidated damages when the employee does not have a claim for unpaid wages".1
Justice Wecht disagreed, in a dissenting opinion.1 He wrote that the decision "hollows out the WPCL's primary mechanism for ensuring that employers pay their workers on time".2
What did not change
The add-on still exists, with its deadlines and its good faith rule, in 43 P.S. § 260.10.1
The law also says that when a worker wins a judgment in a WPCL lawsuit, the court must also allow reasonable attorneys' fees, paid by the defendant (the party sued).1
In plain terms, the add-on now rides on a claim for wages that are still owed.1 A payment made after a case is filed is a different situation, and a lawyer would look at those facts closely.
If this happened to you
Check whether the pay is covered. L&I says paid sick leave, holiday pay and other hours not worked are protected under this wage law only when expressly promised in official business documents, such as an employee handbook or memo.3 Its listed violations include paying late under the pay agreement and not paying the last paycheck when a job ends.3
You do not have to sue: you may instead report a wage claim to the Secretary of Labor and Industry,1 and L&I says it will investigate.3 A claim under this wage law, whether in court or with the state, has to be started within three years of the day the wages were due.1 If you are weighing an add-on claim, talk with a lawyer about the timing, because the Court tied the claim to wages still unpaid when the case starts.1
Questions about how this affects you?
If you were hurt at work, or a late paycheck is tangled up with an injury, and you want to understand your options, you can talk with a lawyer at CM Injury at (267) 936-2233. The conversation is free and confidential.
Sources
- Aita v. NCB Management Services, No. 25 MAP 2025 (Pa. Oct. 29, 2026), majority opinionUnified Judicial System of Pennsylvania (pacourts.us)
- Aita v. NCB Management Services, No. 25 MAP 2025 (Pa. Oct. 29, 2026), dissenting opinion (Wecht, J.)Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania (pacourts.us)
- PA Department of Labor and Industry: File a Wage Payment and Collection Complaintpa.gov
Attorney Advertising. CM Injury (Cavaliere & Mangiaracina, PLLC), 161 Washington Street, Suite 1010, Conshohocken, PA 19428. Reviewed by Frank Mangiaracina. (267) 936-2233.
This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts.
Images: Illustration.
How we report: our sources, fact-checking and corrections.


